Saturday, June 16, 2012

Differences in Facilitation Strategies between Asynchronous and Synchronous Learning


“Computers don’t teach people; people teach people” (Finkelstein, 2006, p. 65). Instructor facilitation is an important part of online learning as it directs the student interaction, student engagement, and classroom effectiveness. Though some facilitation strategies are in both asynchronous and synchronous learning environments, each strategy creates a different effect, on the environment in which it is used. Below are some of the facilitation strategies for asynchronous and synchronous learning environments unique to each environment.



Asynchronous Facilitation:


·         Have all of materials and resources available and accessible for students

·         Organization of classroom resources and forums for easy navigation

·         Create a forum or give instruction to ask questions

·         Establish the time frame when feedback is shared, example: within 24 hours, within 48-72 hours, etc.

·         Have a written explanation of directions and use images or audio to enhance information

·         Avoid overuse of technology

·         Include general instructions of to use necessary technology for the class

·         Use clear verbiage to avoid confusion

·         Include pre-training prior to the learning of complex information



Synchronous Facilitation:

·         Start with a warm welcome

·         Include an appropriate ice-breaker to engage the class

·         Add the human element by treating the class as if they were in the same room, actively listening, using facial expressions and reading students’ queues.

·         Make everyone believe they are included

·         Do not dominate every discussion. Encourage and facilitate conversations and connections.

·         Incorporate student engagement every three to five minutes

·         Have a thorough familiarity with web 2.0 tools (especially tools that encourage interaction) is important to use appropriately tools for real-time class sessions, trouble shoot technology issues and maintain flow

·         Give learners insight and assignments prior to the discussion or activity to prepare them to participate in future discussions and activities.

·         Allow time for learners to practice, participate, and ask questions.

·         Develop lessons and activities to keep interest and interactions high.

·         Keep stress levels low: offer specific ways for learners to contribute. For example, learners more comfortable speaking to participate may use the microphone or phone to comment. Also allow learners who may need time to gather their thoughts or feel more comfortable typing their thoughts to type out their responses.

·         Include an agenda and refer to it as each activity listed is completed.

·         State the objective of the lesson or activity to help students to follow along or to help them understand the flow

·         Stick to the time allotted for the real-time session, start, and end on time

·         Inform students of resources available to them in connection with the real-time session

·         Include reminders of classroom courtesies to avoid unnecessary distractions



Reference:

Finkelstein, J. (2006). Learning in real time: Synchronous teaching and learning online.

            San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.


Friday, June 15, 2012

Advantages and Disadvantages of Asynchronous Learning

 
Advantages of Asynchronous learning:

·         Gives students time to read the material and form a response
·         Students aren’t subjected to be online at specific day or time
·         Students can respond to comments posted on their time
·         Accommodate students from any where in world and in any time zone
·         Student can post at time convenient to them


Disadvantages of Asynchronous learning:

·         A feeling of being disconnected
·         Loss of motivation and or interest 
·         Loss of learning and retention of material
·         When instructor doesn’t intervene to help motivate students
·         All lead to failure of students’ success in the class
·         Students can become negative against the learning process and the instructor
·         A Student can begin to see the course as burden or obstacle instead of a gainful learning experience
·         Students can then become negative in the main forum as a result, impacting other students


Reference:
Asynchronous Learning Advantages and Disadvantages. (2009). Retrieved from
            http://jamesballou.com/Tabula/?p=32
Learning Modalities Comparison. (2011). Retrieved from

Blog Appropriate for Subject Matter

The subject matter included comparisons of synchronous and asynchronous learning which shows us some of the pros and cons of each style. We also discussed some of the differences facilitation strategies. Using a block for this subject matter allowed us to post our sections so that we can each view each other work. Blogs can also be used as classroom management tools to update a class on assignments and to post handouts. Blogs are also useful as collaboration tools because it allows a place for students to practice and also receive feedback from peers. Blogs can also be used as a medium to facilitate discussion between class members on a topic (Blog Spot, 2006). 

Reference:

Blog Spot. (2006, November 14). The use of blogs in education. Retrieved from

Blog Applied to Learning Environment

Instructors need to consider subject matter, classroom size, teaching delivery techniques, and student’s learning styles when developing lesson plans.  Blogs are an easy way instructors can deliver curriculum effectively, achieve learning objectives, and create a desirable learning environment. Designing and maintaining a blog requires basic skill sets of reading, writing, and technology from the instructor and students thereby making blogs multi-functional. Numerous blogging tutorials on the Internet assist new blogging instructors and students become comfortable with using the technology (Gagatiga, 2012).

Instructors can use blogs for students individual and group collaboration efforts. Instructors can assign individual students specific topics for posting new blog commentary and the rest of the class can provide feedback and comments thereby making the dialog interactive and collaborative. The students can discuss the subject matter, share ideas, and engage in alternate conversations stemming from the main topic.

An instructor can use a blog in the classroom to:
·         Document websites and online resources that students can reference easily
·         Post weekly agendas, schedules, and activities
·         Reflect on weekly reading materials and group discussions
·         Perform research on weekly topics and provide feedback
·         Keep track of input and progression for a group project
·         Share classroom learning experiences
·         Elaborate on classmates blogs by adding images, videos or inspirational quotes
·         Ask for professional feedback on their blog writing style
·         Invite students from other local schools and abroad to collaborate on topics

Reference:
Gagatiga, Z. (2012). School librarian in action:  Full paper – blogs in action.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Synchronous Learning

Advantages of Synchronous Learning:
·         Students can participate from any location in the world
·         Can see and hear each other through video conferencing
·         Aids in students feeling engaged with the instructor and peers
·         Students can ask questions and get instant feedback
·         Students don’t have to post or e-mail then wait for a response

Disadvantages of Synchronous Learning:
·         Have to be online at a specific time selected by the instructor
·         More dominant students might monopolize the conversation
·         Inconvenience of students having to be online from different time zones
·         Might be uncomfortable for less assertive students
·         Might be intimidating for less technology savvy students
·         Must respond immediately to questions asked


Reference:
Asynchronous Learning Advantages and Disadvantages. (2009). Retrieved from
            http://jamesballou.com/Tabula/?p=32
Learning Modalities Comparison. (2011). Retrieved from


Differences Between the Facilitators and the Learners in Asynchronous and Synchronous Learning

Asynchronous Environment


Facilitators
Learners
Longer processing time to give feedback
Engagement of learner varies
Limited in ways to encourage interaction among learners
Higher level of independence
Distant, no human believed connection

Little to no connection with facilitator and other classmates
Clarity in writing is necessary

Possibility of higher stress and miscommunication amongst teams due to  misinterpretation of written tone and comprehension of message

Requires better communication and more coordination of schedules and projects

Possibility of having low level of accountability


Synchronous Environment


Facilitators
Learners
Feedback and answers to questions given instantaneously
More involved in activities and discussions

More likely to create a stronger facilitator/learner bond
Increased feeling of accountability to other learners
Can have in-depth discussions with learners
Higher possibility of creating a strong class bond amongst learners and facilitator
Limited on real-time interactions

Existing dependence on classmate and facilitator interaction and assistance


Reference:

Finkelstein, J. (2006). Learning in real time: Synchronous teaching and learning online.

                   San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

Thursday, June 14, 2012

Blog Selected as Delivery Medium

We choose to use a blog for our assignment this week because it is an excellent collaboration tool and it gives us practice in using a medium of communication that is fairly new to some of us.
Blogs help keep students engaged and interested in the learning experience (Blog Spot, 2006). Blogs are accessible to anyone anywhere in the world there is Internet connectivity, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Students do not need to subscribe to a blog service because basic blogging is complimentary (Blog Spot, 2006).

Reference:

Blog Spot. (2006). The use of blogs in education. Retrieved from

http://thanhnguyen75.blogspot.com/2006/11/use-of-blogs-in-education_14.html